
By Michael Allison, CFA

🔄 An Orderly Rebalancing, For Now
When investors build portfolios, they generally focus on correlations between asset classes - stocks, bonds, cash, alternatives, etc. But there’s another type of correlation that’s worth paying attention to: intra-asset class correlations. I think this week’s chart shines an interesting light on that dynamic, in this case the S&P 500.
Quick refresher. Beta measures how much a stock moves with the market. A beta of 1 moves in lockstep, 0.5 moves half as much. A negative beta means the stock has tended to go up on the days the S&P 500 goes down, or down on the days it goes up. Evercore ISI measures it over 6 months of daily returns.
For most of the last 35 years, negative-beta names were close to 0% of the index’s weight. Today Evercore counts 191 of them (up from 130 in October), worth 27.6% of the S&P 500. The prior record was 26.3%, set in 2000-01.
So what’s going on? Concentration. The 10 largest stocks were 37.3% of the index at the end of September, and most of that weight reflects the so-called AI trade. When a handful of megacaps drive the index’s daily moves, the index effectively becomes the AI trade. Anything priced off something else (energy off oil, utilities off interest rates) starts to look inversely correlated almost by default.
And as the AI leaders have stumbled, the money leaving them has mostly walked across the street. Sell some megatech, buy energy and consumer staples, for example. The index absorbs the hit at the top and gets a lift from everything underneath. That’s why the S&P 500 has held up reasonably well while some of its biggest names have bled. It’s a rotation inside the house.
I have called that healthy, and still do. A market with two engines is sturdier than a market with one.
But look at the chart again. The 2000-01 spike collapsed almost as fast as it formed. Old-economy stocks rallied while the Nasdaq cratered, right up until they didn’t, and in 2002 the S&P 500 lost about 22% with very few places to hide.
What might flip the switch this time?
Forced selling. Margin calls and leveraged ETFs rebalancing into the close. In a real deleveraging, investors sell what they can, and correlations approach 1 (see 2008, or March 2020).
Passive flows reversing. Index funds sell every name pro rata. Outflows hit the “hedges” as hard as the AI names.
Rates. Long-duration tech (increasingly debt reliant) and rate-sensitive utilities both get hit by a spike in yields. Same driver, same direction.
An earnings recession. The rest of the market is strong partly because the economy is. Take that away and the cushion goes with it.
The takeaway from this week’s chart is simple. Diversification within stocks is real, and it’s working right now. But it depends on orderly behavior, and it has a habit of disappearing exactly when you need it. Explicit protection (bonds paying real yields, cash, or put options on the index) doesn’t depend on stocks behaving themselves.
An orderly rebalancing, for now. I’ll take it. I just wouldn’t bet a retirement on it staying orderly.
Sources: S&P 500 negative beta weight tops dot-com bubble, Evercore (Seeking Alpha), S&P 500 Breaks Dot-Com Record as 191 Stocks Defy Index (TipRanks), Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills (Damodaran, NYU Stern)
Interested in reading more of Mike's weekly newsletters? Click below to view The Sunday Drive.




